Around town, a story is heard about two thieves named Evgenya and Ilya who went to plunder the northern cave years ago but Ilya never returned. At the church The Hero, Carver and Milly met Evgenya who is now old and she asks if they would like to rest. Upon the party waking up in Amor's past, the town's water began to turn blood red and the townspeople blame Evgenya and Ilya who went to the cave. Upon arriving they found Evgenya trying to wash blood off her sword that won't come off and Ilya is nowhere to be found. Further into the cave they found an injured Ilya fighting a monster. After rescuing him he is reunited with Evgenya and they properly thank and reward the party before leaving. After returning to town to rest again, the party woke up in the present where Ilya comes to visit Evgenya. After talking to them again they are rewarded with the Mirror Key.